The Economic Failure Codex

The Economic Failure Codex

33. Risk-Pool Fragmentation and Insurance Retreat U2

Family III. Cost, Risk & Liability Externalisation · EFC-032

SystemIndividual / Household; Institution / State; Market / Value Chain
DamageCoordination / Resilience; Risk; Φ
For lay readers“Insuring only the houses that never burn”
Key academicGeorge Akerlof (1970, 'The Market for Lemons', Quarterly Journal of Economics)
Exemplarinsurers retreating from flood-prone postcodes after Lismore (2022).
mechanism Selection Over Pooling: Insurers profit by identifying and pricing out bad risks, so the pooling function that makes insurance socially valuable is progressively dismantled. Those who most need coverage face the highest prices or none. suggest edit
mechanism Climate Retreat: Withdrawal from flood-, fire- and cyclone-exposed regions pushes the risk back onto households and onto the state as insurer of last resort. The industry retains the premiums from the good years and exits before the losses. suggest edit
mechanism Participation Consequence: An uninsurable home or an uninsurable body is a direct participation-floor failure: the household cannot borrow, cannot sell, cannot recover. suggest edit
balance condition Balance Condition, Pooling and Risk Discipline: Too little pooling leaves individuals carrying risks they cannot diversify; complete insulation from controllable risk can create moral hazard. The useful range pools catastrophic and genuinely non-diversifiable risks whilst retaining proportionate incentives to prevent losses where the insured party can reasonably control them. suggest edit
remediation Candidate Interventions / Stewardship Responses: Guarantee a universal risk pool for catastrophic and non-diversifiable risks (public or tightly regulated insurance), with community rating, so the healthy are not creamed and the exposed abandoned. suggest edit
for lay readers For Lay Readers: "Insuring only the houses that never burn"; key academic: George Akerlof (1970, 'The Market for Lemons', Quarterly Journal of Economics); exemplar: insurers retreating from flood-prone postcodes after Lismore (2022). suggest edit

Relationships

Suggest a change to this item

edit fields add a mechanism / note add a relationship correct the citation