146. State-Capacity and Implementation Failure Without Capture U2
Family VI. Institutional, Political & Sovereign Capture
· EFC-147
| System | Institution / State |
| Damage | Coordination / Resilience; Institutional / Trust; NRV |
| For lay readers | “Wants to help, can't deliver” |
| Key academic | — |
| Exemplar | well-designed programmes failing in implementation through thin administration |
mechanism
Good-Faith Incapacity: Government fails to deliver not through capture or predation but through genuine incapacity: thin administrative capability, poor information, weak execution, coordination gaps between agencies, and implementation failure. The steward's intent is public-serving; its reach exceeds its grasp. suggest edit
mechanism
The Knowledge and Execution Gap: Central authorities lack the local, tacit information to implement well, and even well-designed policy fails in execution, leaving the community with unmet need and no extraction to blame (Scott 1998). suggest edit
mechanism
Capacity Starvation: Chronic under-resourcing of the public sector (item P65 [Fiscal Secession]) degrades the very capability implementation requires, so failure compounds: weak capacity begets poor outcomes, which begets distrust, which begets further withdrawal of resources. suggest edit
balance condition
Balance Condition, State Capacity and Market Reliance: Government is not automatically capable, nor markets automatically superior; the pathology is incapacity without corruption, which calls for capability-building, not the assumption that public failure is always capture. Intervention risk: capacity-building can be captured or become bureaucratic self-perpetuation. suggest edit
remediation
Candidate Interventions / Stewardship Responses: Invest in state capacity (recruitment, training, institutional knowledge, information systems, coordination), value execution as well as policy design, and build feedback loops so implementation failure is visible and corrected. suggest edit
for lay readers
For Lay Readers: "Wants to help, can't deliver"; key academic: James Scott (1998, Seeing Like a State); exemplar: well-designed programmes failing in implementation through thin administration. suggest edit
framing prose
Distinction from Item P61 [Institutional Sabotage and Regulatory Capture]: Capture vs good-faith incapacity. suggest edit
framing prose
Distinction from Item E1 [Institutional Forgetting and Protective-Purpose Decay]: Memory decay vs execution failure. suggest edit
framing prose
Relation to Item P65 [Fiscal Secession and Public-Capacity Erosion]: Capacity starvation as a cause of implementation failure. suggest edit
Suggest a change to this item
edit fields add a mechanism / note add a relationship correct the citation
